Thursday, August 28, 2008

Does This Offend You?


A modern art sculpture portraying a crucified green frog holding a beer mug and an egg that Pope Benedict has condemned as blasphemous may have its days numbered.

The board of the Museion museum in the northern city of Bolzano are meeting today to choose whether to side with the pope and other opponents of the frog or with proponents who say it should be defended as a work of art.

The wooden sculpture by the late German artist Martin Kippenberger depicts a frog about 1 meter (4 feet) high nailed to brown cross and holding a beer mug in one outstretched hand and an egg in another.

Called “Zuerst die Fuesse,” (Feet First), it wears a green loin cloth and is nailed through the hands and the feet in the manner of Jesus Christ. Its green tongue hangs out of its mouth.

Kippenberger’s work has been shown at the Tate Modern and the Saatchi Gallery in London and at the Venice Biennale, and retrospectives are planned in Los Angeles and New York.

Museum officials in the northern bi-lingual Alto Adige region near the Austrian border said the artist, who died in 1997, considered it a self-portrait illustrating human angst.
Pope Benedict, who is German himself and was recently on holiday not far from Bolzano, obviously did not agree.

The Vatican wrote a letter of support in the pope’s name to Franz Pahl, president of the regional government who opposed the sculpture.

“Surely this is not a work of art but a blasphemy and a disgusting piece of trash that upsets many people,” Pahl told Reuters by telephone as the museum board was meeting.
The Vatican letter said that the work “wounds the religious sentiments of so many people who see in the cross the symbol of God’s love.”

Pahl, whose province is heavily Catholic, was so outraged by the sculpture of the pop-eyed amphibian that he went on a hunger strike to demand its removal and had to be taken to hospital during the summer.

The museum then moved the statue out of its foyer and into a less trafficked area on the third floor.

But Pahl’s opposition was unflagging and he has threatened to resign as regional president unless it is removed altogether.

Art experts defend the work. “Art must always be free and the artist should not have any restrictions on freedom of expression,” Claudio Strinati, a superintendent for Rome’s state museums, told an Italian newspaper on Thursday.

So…does this offend you? Yes or no? Why or why not?

6 comments:

  1. It does offend me, but I'm a big believer in free speech, so let it stay. This isn't nearly as bad as the Piss Christ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piss_Christ).

    My gripe isn't that they shouldn't be allowed to do this. My gripe is with art. I've never understood art. I don't see how people can draw a square and sell it for $10,000. Or maybe they put on a blindfold and throw paint on a canvas and it becomes a "masterpiece".

    Whatever happened to art that was real?

    ReplyDelete
  2. It offends me too. But I can look the other way. Christ would. So let them have their controversy and make their extra dough off of it. Judgment will come and maybe already has for the artist who is no longer living.

    I don't understand art either. I'd rather frame my kid's paintings and drawings. They seem to have more talent at 2 and 3 than these "artists" do at 30.

    Heidi Reed

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is just stupid. I think it was done to offend on purpose so I refuse to be offended.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nope. Not offended.

    Short answer day for me!

    ReplyDelete
  5. It doesn't offend me -- very little actually does.

    It does, however, sadden me greatly, because it indicates that the "artist" does not have the love or peace of Christ, and therefore feels the need to "strike" out in the only way he thinks is effective.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am not offended and the more people draw attention by being offended the more the artist probably feels he has accomplished his purpose. I do agree with Karma. This proves that the man does not have a personal relationship with Jesus and that makes me sad.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for sharing your thoughts! I can't wait to read what you have written.